Is Carnegie Investment Counsel a Fiduciary? Fees, Ownership & SEC Record (2026 Profile)

Truthifi Bot

·

Published

·

Updated

Sign up free

Carnegie Investment Counsel — Truthifi fact check: fiduciary status, fees, and SEC/FINRA record
Truthifi sign-up promo

Want to hook AI up to your finances?

Get started—it’s free

Is Carnegie Investment Counsel a Fiduciary? Fees, Ownership & SEC Record (2026 Profile)

Truthifi Bot

·

Published

·

Updated

Carnegie Investment Counsel — Truthifi fact check: fiduciary status, fees, and SEC/FINRA record
Truthifi sign-up promo

Want to hook AI up to your finances?

Get started—it’s free

Is Carnegie Investment Counsel a Fiduciary? Fees, Ownership & SEC Record (2026 Profile)

Truthifi Bot

·

Published

·

Updated

Carnegie Investment Counsel — Truthifi fact check: fiduciary status, fees, and SEC/FINRA record
Truthifi sign-up promo

Want to hook AI up to your finances?

Get started—it’s free

Find out where you stand.

Connect your accounts and unlock ways to save in minutes.

No commissions, no ads, no advice. This Carnegie Investment Counsel profile draws only on public records, each linked so you can confirm it yourself.

The short answer: is Carnegie Investment Counsel a fiduciary?

Yes. Carnegie Investment Counsel is a fiduciary: as a fee-only registered investment adviser, it owes you a duty to act in your best interest for the whole advisory relationship, and it isn't a broker-dealer. Carnegie Investment Counsel is an SEC-registered investment adviser (CRD #150488) and reported $7.5 billion in regulatory assets under management as of its latest Form ADV (filed July 9, 2026), across 3,281 clients. Because it's fee-only, it's paid by clients and earns no commissions on products. Its Form ADV (Item 5.E) lists how it is paid: a percentage of assets under management, hourly charges, and fixed fees. None of this asks you to take anyone's word for it: the public filings have it, and they're quick to read.

Its Form ADV doesn't report a broker-dealer registration or a related broker-dealer, so the adviser's fiduciary standard is the one that applies to its advice.

What "fiduciary" means: a fiduciary is a financial professional legally required to act in your best interest, putting your interests ahead of its own. (More on fiduciary duty)

Carnegie Investment Counsel at a glance

✅ Verified from public filings, last checked October 5, 2026. Carnegie Investment Counsel (SEC CRD #150488) is a fiduciary for the whole advisory relationship, on a fee-only basis, with $7.5 billion in regulatory assets under management. Every figure below links to its primary source.

What

Carnegie Investment Counsel

Source

SEC CRD

#150488

IAPD

Registration

Registered investment adviser (RIA), not a broker-dealer

IAPD

Registered since

April 30, 2009 (SEC)

IAPD

Fiduciary?

Yes, for the whole advisory relationship (fee-only RIA)

SEC adviser standard

Fee model

Fee-only

Form ADV Item 5.E

How it's paid

A percentage of assets under management, hourly charges, and fixed fees

Form ADV Item 5.E

Regulatory Assets Under Management

$7.5 billion (Form ADV filed July 9, 2026)

IAPD

Client accounts

8,541 (8,266 discretionary)

IAPD

Employees

69 (39 in advisory roles)

IAPD

Ownership

Parent-owned

Form ADV Schedule A

Disclosures

Form ADV answers Yes to one or more disciplinary questions. Read them on IAPD

IAPD

HQ

Pepper Pike, OH

IAPD

Carnegie Investment Counsel fees: what you'll pay

Here's what Carnegie Investment Counsel charges, and where those fees come from. Carnegie Investment Counsel is fee-only: its Form ADV (Item 5.E) reports client-paid fees, such as a percentage of assets, hourly or fixed fees, and no commissions. That structure avoids commission conflicts. Fee-only doesn't automatically mean low-cost. It means the cost is the advisory fee, stated plainly. Its Form ADV (Item 5.E) lists how it is paid: a percentage of assets under management, hourly charges, and fixed fees.

Fee-only means the firm is paid only by its clients, never by commissions on the products it recommends.

Who owns Carnegie Investment Counsel, and what conflicts does it disclose?

The Carnegie Investment Counsel ownership picture is on file with the SEC. Carnegie Investment Counsel is owned by Old Viking II Trust (with Gary Paul Wagner), as listed in Schedule A of its Form ADV. (Form ADV Schedule A)

Its Form ADV Part 2A describes the firm's conflicts of interest, including how it and its advisers are paid.

Carnegie Investment Counsel SEC record: disclosures

Looking for Carnegie Investment Counsel complaints? Start with the firm's own regulatory filings. Carnegie Investment Counsel's Form ADV answers Yes to one or more disciplinary-history questions. A disclosure can be a regulatory, civil or criminal matter involving the firm or a related person. Read each item in context on IAPD before drawing conclusions. If there are Carnegie Investment Counsel disclosures to read, the public record is where they are, and where they should be read.

On the record, the firm has been registered with the SEC since April 30, 2009, makes notice filings in 37 jurisdictions, and reports 69 employees, 39 of them in investment advisory roles. "Is Carnegie Investment Counsel legit?" comes up a lot. Its registration, CRD and filings are public and verifiable. That confirms it's a real, regulated adviser. The part worth your time is what you're paying and earning.

What Carnegie Investment Counsel reviews won't tell you

Star ratings and client comments describe what working with a firm felt like. They usually don't show what the firm reports to regulators. Before you weigh Carnegie Investment Counsel reviews, check three things this profile takes from the public record.First, how the firm is paid: it reports being paid only by its clients and takes no commissions, which makes it fee-only. Second, who owns it and what conflicts it discloses. Third, whether its Form ADV reports any disciplinary history. Read reviews alongside the record, not instead of it.

How to verify Carnegie Investment Counsel yourself

You can verify everything above yourself in three steps:

  1. SEC adviser record (IAPD): https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/150488.

  2. Form ADV / CRS: linked from the IAPD page.

  3. Confirm the entity: match Carnegie Investment Counsel (CRD #150488, legal name Carnegie Capital Asset Management) so you're reading the right firm.

What Carnegie Investment Counsel does and who it serves

On its Form ADV, Carnegie Investment Counsel reports providing financial planning, portfolio management for individuals, small businesses and institutions, pension consulting, and selection of other advisers.

It reports providing financial planning to 251 to 500 clients in its last fiscal year (Form ADV Item 5.H), a count the form keeps separate from the client totals below.

Its Form ADV (Item 5.D) breaks its clients down by type, at least 3,283 in all:

Client type

Clients

Assets managed

Individuals

1,870

$876 million

High-net-worth individuals

1,186

$5.27 billion

Pension and profit-sharing plans

13

$76 million

Charities

77

$404.4 million

State or municipal government entities

Fewer than 5

$21 million

Other investment advisers

6

$188.2 million

Insurance companies

Fewer than 5

$3.1 million

Corporations or other businesses

129

$670.3 million

It reports 8,541 client accounts, more than the roughly 3,281 clients counted above (many clients hold more than one account), 8,266 discretionary (the firm can trade without asking first) and 275 non-discretionary (Item 5.F). Its main office is in Pepper Pike, OH.

It reports that it or a related person has custody of certain client assets, which brings extra safeguards such as surprise examinations. The specifics are in its Form ADV.

You've vetted the firm. Now make sure the advice runs on the full picture.

Confirming Carnegie Investment Counsel is registered takes a few minutes. Any advisor can only act on what they can see, and what they see is partial: scattered accounts, an old rollover, costs that never surface on a statement. This is where Truthifi comes in.

How Truthifi can help

Truthifi links your accounts read-only and shows what you own, how it's allocated, how it's performing and where the risk sits, including single-stock exposure, returns next to a benchmark, a fee breakdown of the fees on each account, by type, and your Truthifi Score. You can share the accounts you choose with your advisor at Carnegie Investment Counsel.

Prefer your own AI? A paid Truthifi plan lets you connect an AI assistant that supports MCP sign-in, such as Claude. Truthifi Connect is the lighter membership for people who only want to use their own assistant. Questions about your fees need Monitoring or Monitoring Plus+. Get started with Truthifi · See how Truthifi keeps your accounts secure

Ask AI about your Carnegie Investment Counsel accounts

Once your accounts are connected read-only, you can ask in plain English:

  • "What do I own across my Carnegie Investment Counsel accounts and everything else, and how is it allocated?"

  • "What am I really paying in fees across all of these accounts?"

Try it with Truthifi: start for free at app.truthifi.com and run a Monitoring Checkup (limits apply).

No commissions, no ads, no advice: Truthifi is not an investment adviser and doesn't give investment, tax or legal advice. Its access to your bank and brokerage accounts is read-only. Start free (limits apply). Monitoring Checkup is free. Link up to 10 connections, per Truthifi's published plan limits. Plans and limits are on the pricing page → truthifi.com.

Frequently asked questions

Is Carnegie Investment Counsel a fiduciary? Yes. It's a registered investment adviser (CRD #150488), so it owes a fiduciary duty when it advises you. Its Form ADV doesn't report a broker-dealer registration or a related broker-dealer.

Is Carnegie Investment Counsel fee-only? Its Form ADV (Item 5.E) doesn't report commissions as compensation. It's paid by clients through fees such as a percentage of assets, hourly or fixed fees. The fee schedule is in its Form ADV Part 2A.

Who owns Carnegie Investment Counsel? Carnegie Investment Counsel is owned by Old Viking II Trust (with Gary Paul Wagner), as listed in Schedule A of its Form ADV.

Does Carnegie Investment Counsel have complaints or disclosures? Yes. Its Form ADV answers Yes to one or more disciplinary-history questions. Read each item on IAPD, in context. A disclosure is not by itself proof of current wrongdoing.

Is Carnegie Investment Counsel legit? Carnegie Investment Counsel is registered with the SEC (CRD #150488) and its filings are public on the SEC's IAPD site, which confirms it is a real, regulated firm. Registration doesn't tell you whether it's the right fit or what you'll pay, so read the fee and conflict sections of its Form ADV.

Can AI help me check whether I'm getting good value? Yes. Start free (limits apply): the Monitoring Checkup is free and lets you link up to 10 connections. You can also connect an AI assistant you already use (such as Claude). On Monitoring or Monitoring Plus+ you can ask it, in plain English, about the fees on each of your accounts. Truthifi is not an investment adviser and doesn't give investment, tax or legal advice.

About this profile

Truthifi built this profile from the firm's own SEC filings (Form ADV and, where filed, Form CRS). Every page is reviewed by the Truthifi Team before publishing. The Truthifi advisor fact packs are an ongoing series checking U.S. investment advisers against their public filings, one firm at a time.

Read next from the Truthifi blog

More advisor fact packs on Truthifi

A note on sources. The facts on this page come from publicly available documents, Carnegie Investment Counsel's SEC filings, each linked inline so you can verify it yourself (SEC data current as of October 5, 2026). This is general information, not financial or legal advice, and Truthifi is not affiliated with Carnegie Investment Counsel. Regulatory records change, so always confirm against the official sources linked above. Spot something that should be corrected? Email us at support@truthifi.com.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. It should not be construed as a personalized recommendation regarding any investment, financial advisor, or financial product. All calculations use hypothetical scenarios and historical return assumptions; actual results will vary. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified financial professional for guidance specific to your situation. Truthifi is an investment monitoring platform — not a financial advisor, broker-dealer, or tax professional. Truthifi does not manage assets, recommend investments, sell financial products, or provide personalized financial advice. Truthifi earns no revenue from advisor referrals, product commissions, or AUM fees. Statistics and data cited reflect publicly available sources current as of the article’s publication date. Sources are linked throughout.